Picture of Mehul Kar

Mehul Kar

Link to Twitter profile Link to email Link to RSS feed

Aug 22, 2014

Cherry pick commit OUT of history


If you have commits:

1 2 3 4 5

and you want to get rid of commit 3, do this:

# currently on master branch
git checkout -b tmp
git format-patch 4..HEAD --stdout > patch.diff # gets all the commits you want
git reset --hard 2 # go back to good times (before you had commit 3).
git am < patch.diff # apply the patch you generated (this is not squished)

# now you're back to happy times. Depending on what you're
# trying to do, you can:
# 1. delete your master branch and rename tmp to master
# 1. make tmp your feature branch and make PR from it
# 1. or hard reset your master branch and merge tmp into it.

# clean up
rm patch.diff

This happened to me just now when I merged a branch foo into master locally because I didn't want to wait for a PR to get merged. Now, every time I checkout new branch bar from master, it includes commits from foo. Now, when I create a PR from bar into upstream, it includes foo commits. Which would be OK if foo got merged right away. BUT, I ended up changing history on foo (squash/rebase/amend/whatever), so that now bar and foo have divergent histories and you end up having merge conflicts even if bar and foo don't touch the same files.


Want to talk about this post? Email me or send me a toot @mehulkar.